New York City vs Columbus Crew: Summary, H2H Stats, Lineups & Highlights

As New York City prepare to host Columbus Crew on May 10, 2026, with kick-off at 22:30, this USA: Major League Soccer fixture promises high stakes in a tightly contested title race.

New York City, currently 9th in the standings with 12 points from 11 games, trail the leaders by 16 points. They've earned 8 points from 7 home games this season. Their recent form has been weak, with 1 draw and 4 losses in their last five matches. They've shown defensive issues, conceding 11 goals. At the same time, they've displayed limited attacking output with 5 goals scored.

Columbus Crew, sitting 10th with 12 points, enter as underdogs but face a tough test on the road, where they've earned 4 points from 5 games this season. Their recent form has been mixed, with 2 wins, 1 draw and 2 losses in their last five matches. They've shown defensive issues, conceding 7 goals. At the same time, they've displayed a positive attacking record, scoring 8 goals.

Recent meetings between New York City and Columbus Crew have favored New York City, with New York City claiming victory in their most recent clash (3-2). Recent clashes between the two teams have been closely contested.

In their previous league match against D.C. United, New York City recorded a 0-2 defeat while lining up in a 4-2-3-1 formation. Their starting XI featured Freese, Cavallo, Gustavo, Bueno, Tanasijevic, O'Neill, Trewin, Jones, Moralez, Ojeda, Mercau. The formation provided flexibility in midfield, allowing for effective rotation and positional play.

Columbus Crew's last outing came against Minnesota United, where they secured a 2-3 defeat using a 3-4-2-1 system. Their starting XI featured Schulte, Amundsen, Zawadzki, Camacho, Moreira, Picard, Chambost, Habroune, Arfsten, Gazdag, Rossi. This tactical approach balanced risk and reward, adapting dynamically to the flow of the game.

Looking ahead, New York City are expected to maintain their unknown structure, New York City and Columbus Crew are expected to use their standard structures. The contest is set to revolve around midfield control, pressing efficiency, and how effectively each side manages transitions between defense and attack.

Goal trends from the last ten games across all competitions suggest plenty of goals: New York City's fixtures have averaged 3.8 goals per game, with 6 going over 2.5 and both teams scoring in 70% of those matches, alongside 0 clean sheets. Columbus Crew's games average 3.1 goals, with 7 going over 2.5 and both teams scoring in 70% of those matches, alongside 2 clean sheets. With both sides capable in attack, expect goals at both ends.

ScoresFeed.com is covering New York City vs Columbus Crew in real time, providing live score of the match, team line-ups, full match stats, and live match commentary.